IP BLOG 2: ON FAITH


Having attended a Catholic primary school, despite being ‘C of E’, meant that I would have to ‘sit out’ while others participated in their holy communion. I didn’t particularly mind. As a child, my experience of religion was that I quite enjoyed the singing, and didn’t feel it had much bearing on my life. And at secondary school, my R.E. lessons gave some idea that there were different ways of doing things. Although omitted what Kwame Appiah offers as a light-hearted aside during his talk: “The internal history of Christianity is largely the history of people killing each other because they believed the wrong thing.” He explains how European travellers from a Christian culture around the time of Columbus viewed religions through the lens of, “What have they got instead of Christianity?” His talk falls just short of pointing out that, ‘in our overwhelmingly dominant white places of teaching and learning’ (Mirza, 2018, p187) reality is a plurality and that looking at ways of being and doing as ‘other’ isn’t usually helpful, considerate, constructive, or conducive to learning.

Though I never identified as religious, I’ve practiced mindfulness for the past seven years and trained to become a mindfulness meditation teacher. Guided by Julian Daizan Skinner and Hogets Baerndal at Imperial College during a space-suit research project, I was drawn to this field from a secular scientific perspective.

Fig.1: UAL Dashboard: Student profiles 23/24

Fig.1. Shows that religious students are in the minority at UAL. The 12.2% who prefer not to say and the and 2.3% unknown, also feel significant as a group who do not wish to disclose. Perhaps simply feeling the institution does not need to know. Or one of many possible explanations is, ‘the ‘disjunction’ between how they see themselves and how they are racially constructed as a ‘female Muslim other’. As students particularly face ‘anti-Islamic hostility in Britain’ (Mirza p186)

The more I learn about Zen and Buddhism, particularly the work of Thich Nhat Hanh, the more I see faith as helpful to health and wellbeing. It follows that I have a certain privilege, in addition to being white and European, in being ‘outside’ the religion, not brought up with it, as I select ideas that feel helpful for me. I must continue to interrogate my evolving relationship with faith engaging with the perspectives of all religions and de-centring my white Christian upbringing in my teaching. As, ‘Non-religious subjects can be epistemically harmed, since they miss out on the ‘intuitive knowledge” (Reki 2023 p782)

Specifically in fashion it is important to acknowledge the intersectional experience of Muslim female students being, ‘stereotyped as either ‘passive or oppressed’’ in relation to clothing. (Mirza 2018 p185) and the negative impact on belonging, learning, and awarding.

Faith can guide people through their lives, give hope, and a sense of peace and community. It is especially unfortunate then that people experience prejudice and discrimination, often based on generalisations of religion. Professor Simran Jeet Singh mentions the, ‘Criminalisation of people based on how they look or what they believe’ and describes how humanity and empathy, ‘allows us to engage with difference in a way that is constructive rather than destructive’. As well as the need to educate on, ‘how methods of fear-mongering contribute to the garnering of political power’. Solidifying my role in helping people navigate the attention economy we live in, where polarisation is advantageous for clicks, views and votes but not for people ourselves.

‘The significance of religious belief in people’s lives should not be underestimated’. (jawad 2022) And in knowing that, ‘Identities intersect to produce different harms for different religious subjects who must constantly negotiate their lives in spaces that are at once secular and shaped by the norms of a dominant religious worldview.’ (P780 Reki) I feel that Faith, mindfulness and ways of being instead of doing, can provide practical methodologies and some of the softness that is the antidote to a damaging ‘hustle culture’.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Appiah, K. A. (2014). Is religion good or bad? (This is a trick question). [YouTube video]. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2et2KO8gcY. Accessed 03.05.2024.

Daizan, (Skinner Julian) and Baerndal, Hogets (2024), About Our Teachers, Zenways [Online]. Available at https://zenways.org/about-our-teachers/ Accessed 30.05.2024

Reki, J. (2023) Religious Identity and Epistemic Injustice: An Intersectional AccountHypatia 38, pp779–800. Accessed 30.05.2024

Trinity University (2016) Challenging Race, Religion, and Stereotypes in the Classroom. [Online]. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0CAOKTo_DOk Accessed 30.05.2024

Mirza, Heidi. (2018). Black Bodies ‘Out of Place’ in Academic Spaces: Gender, Race, Faith and Culture in Post-race Times: Racism, Whiteness and Decolonising the Academy. 10.1007/978-3-319-60261-5_10. Accessed 25.05.2024

Jawad, H. (2022) Islam, Women and Sport: The Case of Visible Muslim Women. [Online]. Available at: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/religionglobalsociety/2022/09/islam-women-and-sport-the-case-of-visible-muslim-women/ Accessed 30.05.2024

FIGURES

Figure 1: (2024) UAL data on Student religion: Internal dashboard [Online]. Available at https://dashboards.arts.ac.uk/dashboard/ActiveDashboards/DashboardPage.aspx?dashboardid=5c6bb274-7645-4500-bb75-7e334f68ff24&dashcontextid=638526966971316492 Accessed 30.05.2024


4 responses to “IP BLOG 2: ON FAITH”

  1. Thanks Emma for another thoughtful blog post. I had no idea of your expertise in mindfulness meditation. I’m curious if/how you bring ideas of mindfulness and/or religious inclusion into your teaching? It would be great if you could share a couple of practical examples to expand upon your thinking so far.

    • Thank you Carys!

      I think religious inclusion for me is currently happening on a more individual basis and I can think of examples of students particularly exploring modest wear and the significance of headscarves and hijab in their projects. Having these discussions with students has produced some meangful essays and design work. As well as students documenting and discussing some of the attitudes encountered and discrimination faced. Also in my current technology project a group of students worked together on creating garments with wearable tech that could be modest but still keep the wearer cool.

      I have many examples of teaching mindfulness meditation and I am trying to figure out how exactly to bring this into my intervention proposal.

      1. Teaching an 8 week course in mindfulness for health and wellbeing – (external to LCF) This I think is the best way to get people into the practice and philosophy and requires about an hour and a half a week in addition to homework’s.

      2. Teaching Mindful Drawing sessions – applying my mindfulness methodologies teaching to drawing classes. This is another favourite of mine because I have taught it many times in many settings and seen good results. At LCF only once though at the Sustainability conference last year.

      3. Teaching Mindfulness Staff Development session online A 30 min lunchtime meditation session taught online during staff development week.

      4. Teaching Mini mindfulness meditation, only lasting about 6 mins at the start of a workshop with Central Saint Martins MA Fashion Students last year. – I got some really good written feedback on this one as it had a positive impact on students attitudes, mindset and outcomes.

      All the best

      Emma

  2. Thank you, Emma, for sharing such a thoughtful reflection on the intersection of faith, education, and mindfulness. Your personal journey from a secular upbringing to embracing mindfulness and exploring various religious perspectives is truly inspiring. Your insights into the challenges faced by religious minorities in educational settings, especially within the context of fashion, are both important and timely. It’s heartening to see how you strive to decentralize your own background to foster a more inclusive and understanding environment for all students. Your commitment to educating about and combating prejudice, while promoting empathy and constructive engagement is a nice example to take forward. Keep up the great work in making learning spaces more welcoming and supportive for everyone.

Leave a Reply to Joao Maraschin Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *